Good Enough, Or Adventures in Plus-Sized Dating

I don't date much. In the span of about 10 months in 2009, I went on about five dates (and two of those were "we didn't really say they were dates but we both knew they were; I could tell by the way smiled an extra 3 seconds at an unfunny joke" type dates). This whirlwind of romantic activity had never happened before, and has not been repeated with such fervour since.

I've often lamented that I hate dating. I get nervous and awkward and, especially if I like the guy, my teeth chatter and feel like I'm going to vomit. My topics of conversation go down weird bunny trails so before I know it, our delightful conversation about some book we mutually enjoy has turned into a systematic recounting of all the ways to effectively poison someone in the 15th century. I adopt a laugh that is not mine, I never like my hair, and I'm too afraid that my lipstick has smudged to even listen to what he's saying.  And who can ever figure out what to do with their hands?!

Part of my fear of and discomfort with dating undeniably stems from the Christian culture I was immersed in throughout those hormonal teen years. I can't count how many Bible studies and "Q & As" about healthy, Godly dating I attended between the ages of 13 and 18; and I can't tell you how much of the advice ranged from the unrealistically chaste ("Don't kiss anyone until you're married!" - a discussion that left me feeling overwhelmingly guilty for snagging that peck from Ben Adams at the water fountain in grade one) to the extremely vague ("You and your partner should decide in your own relationship what constitutes 'going too far'" - a piece of advice that any young Christian can use to justify their actions: for example, "I feel like God really wants us to have sex, even though we're 14 and don't have protection and we're in the woods at camp and people could easily find us and this is really not an ideal situation in any way.").*

So while trying to make sense of this contradictory and confusing information while hormones were a-ragin' (and while we're at it, shout out to all the youth pastors that suffered through these years with us and tried their best to answer our awkward, unanswerable questions), I also was dealing with being fat.

Being chubby when you're a pre-teen is sort of ok. You look cute and innocent like a little cherub, and adults always say things like "oh you'll lose your baby fat soon!" Not only were these presentiments wrong, but when puberty hit I was suddenly covered in acne, sporting bleach-blonde hair with brown roots (because nobody told me dye jobs were supposed to be maintained), and wearing clothes from Northern Reflections at the age of 14 because nothing from anywhere else fit me and we didn't yet have an Old Navy. To add to this recipe for singledom, I was smart and highly in-tune with my emotions, which doesn't make you deep, mysterious, and sexy in high school; it just makes you a weirdo.

And all of this is by no means unique. Everyone suffers - albeit in varying degrees - throughout adolescence. It's a rough time for everyone involved, and we should all give ourselves pats on the back for making it through.

But there was an undercurrent of dialogue in my teen years that worked its way into my brain. It has wormed into my subconscious, nested, and built a nice little home for itself, where to this day it resides and whispers its mantra over and over:

Fat girls are unlovable.

I came to know this truth in many ways. TV shows and movies proclaimed us roly-poly ladies to be excellent best friends and sources for advice, but not adequate romantic partners. Friends and family advised that men are visual creatures, and if only I lost weight or wore clothes that were more slimming, I might get one to notice me. People congratulated me on my periodic weight loss, as if I had finally accomplished something worthy of acknowledgement. Boys would befriend me, tell me their hopes and secrets, and then ask me if my friends were dating anyone.

So, faced with this only possible reality, I politely stepped down from the role of romantic lead. Knowing that I wasn't allowed to be attractive or - heaven forbid - sexy, I gracefully accepted the position of friend and confidant. I could never expect a man to want to date me, so I stopped thinking it would happen. I would slide into the role of "buddy" with any guy I met, because I knew he found me as physically repulsive as I found myself. All of this was going on subconsciously, because I held hope that by being friends with a guy, he would eventually get to know me and look past my exterior to see my soul, which maybe he could then learn to love.

It sounds crazy, but I legitimately didn't realize until about a year ago that being fat doesn't equate with being repulsive.

The problem with this sort of thinking is that it reduces both men and women to empty shells. By telling a woman that it is being a size 6 that will make her a valuable romantic partner, we are saying that legitimately nothing else matters about her. It doesn't matter if she is pretty or funny or intelligent or charming or kind. It also reduces men to brainless droids who only care about sleeping with the women that society says they should. It suggests that they don't value kindness or intelligence or a sense of humour in a partner, as long as she's great arm candy. It also says that if a man asks a fat woman out, she should be grateful that he has given her attention and say yes, regardless of his personality. It's just a disaster all around.

I read this really great poem today by Rachel Wiley called "10 Honest Thoughts On Being Loved By A Skinny Boy" (which you can read here or watch a video of her reading here). It's a poem about feeling insecure in her relationship because she is fat and her boyfriend is skinny, and society dictates that those two body shapes do not belong together, and she is just waiting for the other shoe to drop. One stanza reads (warning: profanity ahead! Proceed with caution):

The phrase "big girls need love too" can die in a fire
Fucking me does not require an asterisk.
Loving me is not a fetish.
Finding me beautiful is not a novelty

I think what's so great about this poem is that I'm starting to believe this. I'm starting to believe that I don't always have to occupy the dreaded friendzone. I'm starting to believe that, in addition to my brain and heart, a man can love me because of my body and not just in spite of it. I am starting to believe that I am good enough to be more than a novelty.

I'm starting to believe that maybe - just maybe - I am dateable.


* note: this did not actually happen to me. I hate the outdoors.

Current book: Mere Christianity - C.S. Lewis
Current TV show: Girls (season 2)
Current nail colour: OPI's "Tickle My France-y"


Anonymous said…
Yes. My response to this is as simple as that, really. One line felt so utterly familiar: "Boys would befriend me, tell me their hopes and secrets, and then ask me if my friends were dating anyone". Yes.

It's hard to reflect on this feeling, one I've felt for a long time myself, and kudos to you for doing it and wonderfully so!
Dayna Curtis said…
Jillian, you and I are so much alike in this regard. I shared all the same thoughts as you did/do. And I'm happy to report that there ARE men out there who look at the heart and not the body. I really struggled with this when stelios and I got engaged. I didn't understand how he could love with so much weight on and he said he is marrying me because of my heart and not my body. So date away! Kiss away! And enjoy! Love you!

Anonymous said…
I am glad that Dayna posted that because as I was reading the blog I felt like I was actually reliving what she would say to me. Don't worry, you're time will come. Maybe God is putting "him" through a refining before he meets you. Keep looking up. Hugs!

Aunt G.
Anonymous said…
I'd date you ... If I were ... Younger!
Anonymous said…
Oops ... Sorry to lead you on. The previous "anonymous" person was me ... aunt marley (known as Marilyn Monroe solely because of my plus size figure)

Anonymous said…
Wow! Your insight into the deeper things of relationships is absolutely profound! Your honesty and openness is refreshing and also show a maturity of soul way beyond your years.

I really enjoy the sensibilities and intelligence of your writings (not that I'm the least bit surprised). We need to "do lunch" sometime, and we don't have to call it a date if you don't want. I'd also be very interested in discussing Mere Christianity with you.

Uncle Wayne
Good on ya!

Popular posts from this blog

The Return (and Some Housekeeping)

Post the Sixth - Thoughts, etc.

On Generosity